Hidden Gem Pizzerias in Orlando You Probably Haven’t Tried Yet

Tired of the same pizza spots? Orlando is packed with hidden gems serving up authentic, delicious, and sometimes unexpected flavors. Here are some low-key favorites locals love — and you will too.

1. Prato
Located in Winter Park, Prato serves modern Italian pizza with house-made dough, truffle oil, and locally sourced toppings. Their “Widowmaker” pizza is unforgettable.

2. Pizza Xtreme
A casual joint with an epic pizza selection. Try the Xtreme Meat Lovers if you’re feeling hungry — it’s stacked with four types of meat and melted cheese.

3. NYPD Pizza
A classic New York-style pizza experience. Known for their crispy thin crust, their pepperoni and extra cheese combo is always a winner.

4. Pie-Zanos
This neighborhood favorite dishes out Italian comfort food, including hand-tossed pizzas with fresh basil, tomatoes, and garlic butter crust.

5. The Pizza Press
Create your own masterpiece with fresh, unlimited toppings at this editorially themed pizza bar. Bonus: super-fast service and gluten-free crusts available.

Skip the usual chain and try one of these underrated pizza joints next time you’re in the mood for something truly satisfying.